VIP Pricing Change (Effective May 1, 2016)

Figured out what I was doing wrong. After clicking on "Become a VIP," I usually just click on the "Buy" button with the $15.00 option (the only option visible) on the right side of the store screen, after which I would input the player name.

What you need to do is first click on "Sandlot VIP," right next to "Home" in the upper left, then type in your player name, which gives you the renew price option.

No need to refund any past overpayments, I'm happy to donate to the Sandlot.